Same Sex, Different States

Buy the Book: AmazonBookshopYale University Press

Title: Same Sex, Different States: When Same-Sex Marriages Cross State Lines
Published by: Yale University Press
Release Date: November 30, 2006
ISBN13: 9780300113402


Must a state in which gay marriage is not legal recognize such a marriage performed in another state? The Constitution does not require recognition in all cases, but it does forbid states from nullifying family relationships based in other states, or from making themselves havens for people who are trying to escape obligations to their spouses and children. In this book, Andrew Koppelman offers workable legal solutions to the problems that arise when gay couples cross state borders. Drawing on historical precedents in which states held radically different moral views about marriage (for example, between kin, very young individuals, and interracial couples), Koppelman shows which state laws should govern in specific situations as gay couples travel or move from place to place.

Americans are profoundly divided over same-sex marriage, and now that gay civil unions and marriages are legal in some states, the issue has become increasingly urgent. Koppelman offers a sensible approach that will appeal to the best instincts of both sides.



Received Honorable Mention for the 2007 Gustavus Myers Outstanding Book Award, given by the Gustavus Myers Center for the Study of Bigotry and Human Rights.

“If same-sex marriages are lawfully performed in one state, must other states recognize those marriages? Koppelman has produced the best discussion, by far, of this important question. In the process, he clarifies a wide range of issues swirling about the same-sex marriage debate. This book is a genuine public service.”
Cass Sunstein, Karl N. Llewellyn Distinguished Service Professor of Jurisprudence, University of Chicago

“A timely addition to the literature.”
Lea Brilmayer, Howard Holtzmann Professor of International Law, Yale Law School

“Koppelman offers workable legal solutions to the problems that arise when gay couples cross state borders, and shows which state laws should govern in specific situations.”
Yale Law Report

“Don't be fooled by the title. This clever little book is about much more than crossing state lines. . . . Seeks nothing less than to use the law to enable people with radically different views about same-sex marriage to live together peaceably. . . . Compelling.”
Susan Burgess, The Law and Politics Book Review

“An excellent resource for all those who may be interested in the debate over same-sex marriages in our mobile society.”
Alison M. Smith, The Federal Lawyer

“By defining the bounds of each state's legitimate authority, Same Sex, Different States demonstrates how well-established choice of law rules offer a reasonable resolution of the culture war over same-sex marriage. . . . [A] well written book.”
Lawrence A. Mandelker, New York Law Journal